• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • Recipes
  • Kitchen Essentials
  • Client Projects
  • About
  • Contact
  • Nav Social Menu

    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • Vimeo
Rosemary Mark

Rosemary Mark

Recipes tried and true by RecipeRose

  • Appetizers & Snacks
  • Wild Yeast Water Breads
  • Breads
  • Sweets
  • Entrees
    • Breakfast
  • Soups, Salads, Sides
  • Vegetarian
  • Brands
  • Wild Yeast Waters
    How to Make Wild Yeast Water

    How to make Wild Yeast Water, the no knead to feed bread starter!

  • How to Make No-Knead Wild Yeast Water Focaccia

    Stir today, focaccia tomorrow! This is a new recipe along with How to Convert Sourdough…

  • One-a-Penny Two-a-Penny Hot Cross Buns

    Hot Cross Buns remind me of this nursery rhyme, but besides the song which is…

  • Seeded Rolls
    The Trick for Seeded Artisan Breads

    – Follow my blog with Bloglovin Post UPDATE! Another way to seed your rolls as demo'd by…

  • WYW Seeded Crackers
    Wild Yeast Water Seeded Crackers

    You've likely heard of sourdough discard crackers for using up extra discard? With wild yeast…

  • Seeded Rolls
    The Trick for Seeded Artisan Breads

    – Follow my blog with Bloglovin Post UPDATE! Another way to seed your rolls as demo'd by…

Hot Bake or Cold Bake — your choice!

Breads, RecipeRose, Wild Yeast Water Breads

Share
Pin
Post
Email
Print
Hot bake vs cold bake comparison

If you’ve been around the artisan bread baking block, you know about super-heated Dutch oven baking—-a dangerously hot task! But did you know that starting the bake in a cold oven works too? I’d been preheating for years until I heard of the cold start method from FoodbodSourdough.

There are differences in results, but by golly either hot bake or cold bake method is excellent. So, it’s your choice!

This is a side-by-side comparison using my Easiest Ever No Knead Bread with wild yeast water.

Click here for how to make your first jar of Yeast Water

You can also use my BAsic Artisan bread Recipe.

I evenly divided the final dough by gram weight then overnight proofed in a cloth lined bowl in the refrigerator. Both breads were baked in my 4.3qt-size Amazon Basics Dutch oven which I’ve used for 5 years and love. (*not a paid advert). The first dough went straight from the refrigerator into the pan then I scored the top. Put it into the cold oven on the highest rack that fits the Dutch oven, which is just above center in my oven. If baked lower in the oven it tends to make darker bottom crust. Turned the oven on to 450F convection (or use 475F conventional). Baked covered for 50 minutes. Removed lid and baked additional 10 minutes in the pan.

Note: For super dark crusty bake, sometimes at this point I remove the bread from the pan and place on the oven rack for another 5-10 minutes. But watch carefully, it browns quickly.

For the hot bake, I returned the same Dutch oven to the hot oven for 10 minutes to be sure it was super heated. Then CAREFULLY transferred the second dough from the refrigerator into the hot pan and scored the top. I cannot emphasize enough how careful you must be handling the hot lid and pan. (So far I’ve only burned my wrist slightly one time). I baked this one covered at 450F convection for 30 minutes then removed the lid and baked additional 15 minutes until the same brownness as the first loaf.

Then, I patiently waited for 3 hours until the breads were cool! It was obvious that the hot bake loaf had a bit more ‘oven spring’ height. Both loaves were equally crusty and very soft crumb. The hot bake has visibly larger holes in the ‘crumb’. Yet, when I started slicing and tasting, I nearly mixed up which I was eating as the texture was so similar. I had five tasters who said the same!

So if it’s oven time, or energy savings, or that you just like tighter crumb (for less ‘stuff’ to fall through), then go for the cold bake. I’ll continue using either, depending if I think my dough needs extra heat boost, or whichever method fits my schedule because that’s one rule I try to keep: don’t let bread dough rule your life!

I hope this helps you and your baking life 🙂 I’d love to hear about your baking!
And try my Apple Date Snack Cake with the spent dates when refreshing your wild yeast water.

Hot cold bake side by side
Cold pan bake (left) Hot pan bake (right)

Top photo: Hot Bake method; Bottom photo: Cold Bake method

Last but not least, these are my favorite and important tools for successful bread baking.

affiliate link

The high capacity baking scale
I use all day long in my kitchen!

Brod & Taylor Folding Proofer

Brod & Taylor Folding Proofer
Share
Pin
Post
Email
Print

8 Comments

Previous Post: « Advent Lebkuchen
Next Post: Authentic Irish Brown Bread »

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Comments

  1. Margaret says

    February 18, 2023 at 11:22 am

    This was very helpful. I’m not baking bread yet, but
    you make get me to try my hand at it yet! Love following all you’re doing!!!

    Reply
  2. Chris says

    February 18, 2023 at 1:41 pm

    Wowowow

    Reply
  3. Rose Gillen says

    February 18, 2023 at 4:39 pm

    So exciting to see the bakes side by side! Who would have ever guessed that they could be so similar? And how wonderful not to have to be so careful with the cold bake–saves a lot of burned skin!

    Reply
    • Rosemary Mark says

      February 18, 2023 at 7:43 pm

      It was so great to see it’s not necessary to super-heat. I really like the savings both in time and electricity. Though I’m always planning multiple things to bake once I crank up the oven for breads!

      Reply
  4. Cynthis says

    February 18, 2023 at 8:25 pm

    I am not a baker but just might try this experiment!

    Reply
    • Rosemary Mark says

      February 20, 2023 at 9:03 pm

      I’d be happy to coach you through some baking!

      Reply
  5. Carolyn Bushey says

    June 15, 2025 at 5:08 am

    In your photos I am seeing a difference in scoring and wonder if that also played a part in the lesser spring in the cold start loaf.
    It appears to me that there was not a complete score across the top of the cold start loaf, do you think it made a difference?
    Thanks for all the information!

    Reply
    • Rosemary Mark says

      June 15, 2025 at 9:26 pm

      Carolyn – thank you for your observation on the scoring. I wish I’d included a before bake photo. I suspect the scores were as similar as I could do and the hot bake expanded a little more than the cold-start bake. Seems worth another test! I use cold-start method periodically and feel it’s acceptable considering the time and heat saving especially in summer.
      Have you tried baking bread with wild yeast water? I’m always curious to hear how folks like this method.

      Reply

Primary Sidebar

Welcome to my kitchen! With an eye for uncomplicated and delicious food, I create
real-life recipes for some of America’s most beloved name brands. Read more.

Join RecipeRose to receive my newest recipes in your inbox.

/* real people should not fill this in and expect good things - do not remove this or risk form bot signups */
I don’t cook spam – or send it!

Browse RecipeRose

  • Appetizers & Snacks
  • Wild Yeast Water Breads
  • Breads
  • Sweets
  • Entrees
    • Breakfast
  • Soups, Salads, Sides
  • Vegetarian
  • Brands

Footer

RECEIVE MY NEWEST RECIPES IN YOUR INBOX.

/* real people should not fill this in and expect good things - do not remove this or risk form bot signups */

Search RecipeRose

RecipeRose on Instagram

Day trip to @pointreyescheese Can’t beat the be Day trip to @pointreyescheese 
Can’t beat the beauty and the CHEESE!! 
Plan ahead for a tasting cheese board 😋
The Forkevents, tastings, gifts, and one of @oprahs.favorite.things 

#sonomacheesetrail 
#daytripping 
#cheesetasting
#staycation
I’ll be here till I decide what to make first! I’ll be here till I decide what to make first! 
‘One new recipe (almost) every day’
#halvah 
#sesameseeds 
#whatsinrosieskitchen 
#homecooking 
#bakemehappy
New favorite cookbook. Let @itsalislagle dream of New favorite cookbook. Let @itsalislagle dream of dinner so you don’t have to!
Keeping up with my ‘One new recipe (almost) every day!’
-Snappy Veg with Broken Caesar
-Spicy Seared Tofu & Broccoli
-Crispy Potato Egg & Cheese Tacos
#homecooking
#newrecipes
#whatsinrosieskitchen
Girl dads eat pink cake! Blood orange juice makes Girl dads eat pink cake! 
Blood orange juice makes the prettiest natural pink frosting. 
Click bio for recipe, listed in Sweets 😋
The cake is probably the most perfectly written cake recipe I’ve ever read — thanks to dear Flo Braker who is greatly missed in our baking world, though her cookbooks live on. Her Buttermilk Cake and Classic White Cakes are in her book The Art of Perfect Baking which you can find on-line or in libraries. I think Flo wouldn’t mind me sharing her recipe. She was a most generous baking friend.

#fathersdaycake 
#homebaking 
#buttermilkcake 
#girldads
Make your own creative grahams! Credit to @thepant Make your own creative grahams! Credit to @thepantrymama for this most excellent recipe. So many options:
Rosemary and Sea Salt (my choice 😉)
Cinnamon Sugar
Cocoa
Cheddar and Pepper
Peanut Butter 
Break out the S’mores of course 😃
#homebaking 
#grahamcrackers 
#smores 
#sourdoughcrackers 
#sourdoughdiscard
#coconutmacaroons #homebaking #glutenfreecookies # #coconutmacaroons #homebaking #glutenfreecookies #bakemehappy #baketheworldabetterplace
From the last to the first steps, the making of an From the last to the first steps, the making of an Almond Marzipan wrapped Princess Cake!  #projectbaking and worth the results! 
Recipe by @kingarthurbaking but please, someone tell me how to prevent the wrap pleats?? Roll thinner, or larger?? I made exactly per recipe 14-inches and 1/8” thick.

#projectbaking 
#weekendbaking 
#bakewithus 
#princesscake 
#almondmarzipancake 
#homebaking

Copyright © 2025 · Rosemary Mark · All Rights Reserved